Canada and the "Third World"

DEVS 100/6.0

Introduces basic theoretical concepts of development studies, the history of global inequality, and short histories of alternative development strategies. Case studies of Canada's ties to the so-called third world will include missionaries, military, business, and aid. Canadian colonialism over First Nations peoples will introduce basic issues in Aboriginal Studies.

Description

This course offers a comprehensive introduction to the field of development studies. It provides students with the initial tools necessary to engage with difficult questions about global development.

  • What is the so called Third World, Fourth World, Global South or “majority world”?
  • Why are some countries so rich while others are so poor?
  • Why are there seemingly intractable pockets of poverty within otherwise wealthy communities?
  • What is development, anyway, and how do we get there?

To begin to engage these questions, the course examines the core perspectives and debates in development thinking and practice mainly since 1950s. We start with analysis of the evolution of development theory and practice, contextualized historically. Using case studies from different parts of the world, we then examine the impacts that key theories about ‘creating development’ have had when put into practice.

The latter part of the course focuses specifically on various aspects of Canada’s relationship to the “Third World.”  Canada’s mixed record as a colonial power over First Nations peoples will also introduce students to basic issues in Aboriginal Studies. From this basis, we can reflect upon the complexities, ambiguities and contradictions found beneath popular stereotypes of Canadian “niceness” or support for “Third World” aspirations. What choices might Canadian citizens take to shape their relationship with the “Third World” in the future?

The course will include weekly tutorial interaction through Moodle-based discussion groups designed to allow students to analyze and reflect on key topics covered in the course with smaller groups of their peers. The course will also make substantial use of documentary films to supplement and illustrate the materials covered in course readings and online course notes.

Learning Outcomes:

On completing this full credit course, it is expected that students will have a good understanding of the following:

1.

The main perspectives and debates in development thinking in order to evaluate their strengths and weaknesses as explanatory frameworks of development and underdevelopment in the "Third World";

2.

The usefulness of employing inter disciplinary approaches to better engage the problems of development and underdevelopment;

3.

The competing perspectives on development and how they are connected to particular periods, political interests and concerns;

4.

Key issues in contemporary development, including Canada's place in international development;

5.

The academic skills needed to succeed in development studies; including tutorial participation, essay and exam writing, and the presentation of complex ideas and arguments.

Evaluation

Participation  10%  =10%

Your grade is based on informed and timely engagement with the course materials in your online tutorial discussion group. This includes the completion of specific requested tasks and engagement with some of your peers’ contributions. You are expected to make your initial post dealing with the week’s discussion questions by Thursday morning. You will not see other student’s comments until you have posted your own. Your participation in follow up discussion must be completed by Monday morning to count towards your participation grade. There is no set number of posts each week. You must engage with the week’s discussion questions and the ideas presented by your peers. We value contributions that engage thoughtfully with the course materials, ask interesting questions, and generally move the discussion forward. We will be emphasizing quality more than quantity when grading participation.

Mid-Term  = 15 %

Take home exam delivered and submitted electronically.

Quizzes  2 x 10% =20%

Timed multiple choice quizzes administered online through Moodle.

Research Paper

You are free to choose ANY topic related to the themes being dealt with in the course; however the paper must include some kind of Canadian context (Canadian government, business, NGO, citizen, etc. involvement or official stance on the issue). This assignment consists of a proposal and a final paper.

Proposal =10%

Your proposal must have a working title, a short description of your topic, a brief synopsis of the controversies surrounding the topic, and a tentative outline of your paper all written in paragraph form. It should be 500 words (approximately 2 pages) long and have an attached bibliography with a minimum of six sources, at least three of which must be academic journal articles. The proposal will allow us to determine if the paper that you are planning to write is appropriate for the course and is doable within the allotted time. Papers may not be submitted without a pre-approved proposal.

Paper  25% =25%

The paper should identify the relevant controversies and issues surrounding the topic and provide a critical analysis with a clear argument. Avoid vague, general papers, and select a topic specific enough to be handled in a brief essay. The paper should be 8 to 10 pages, double-spaced and must use a minimum of 10 sources. The majority of your sources should be scholarly articles, but you can also consult books, journalism and official documents. Sources should be cited according to standard scholarly conventions (see the section on Essay Format below). NB. Wikipedia is not an acceptable academic reference.

Final Exam  20% =20%

Essay Format

All submissions must be double-spaced, 12cpi Times New Roman. The Department of Sociology at Queen's has prepared a very thorough Style and Reference Guide for Undergraduate essays (PDF). We strongly recommend that you adhere to its advice about writing, particularly the points about reification, thesis statements, wordiness, quotations, and assumptions. We require that you follow the bibliographic style and in‐text referencing format outlined in the above guide. Make use of footnotes (not endnotes) only for explanatory purposes, e.g., to clarify a point that would otherwise clutter the text or interrupt the flow of your argument; or to note an apparent political slant in your source.

Final Examination

Take home exam delivered and submitted electronically.

Topics

Week

 Topic

 Readings

 Multi Media

1

Introduction to the Course and the Idea of Development

1. McMichael Ch. 1 "Development and Globalization Framing Issues"

 

2

Orientalism and Development

2. Glyn, Meth & Willis, ‘Representing the South’, p. 3-40
3. Razack "Dark Threats and White Knights" Introduction: Savage Wars of Peace

On Orientalism-Edward Said

 

Mickey Mouse Monopoly

3

Theories of Development: Modernization to Neo-Liberalism

4. Desai  "Theories of Development" (Haslam Ch. 3)
5. Rostow, ‘Five Stages of Growth: A Summary' (p. 4-16)
6. Frank, ‘The Development Underdevelopment' (p. 107-117).
7. Klak, ‘World‐Systems Theory' (p. 101-106)

 Ancient Futures: Learning from Ladakh

Rethinking Development: Culture, Gender, and Post Development

8. Sahle "Post Development" (Haslam Ch. 4)
9. Martinez "Gender and Development: Issues and Struggles of Third World Women" (Haslam Ch. 5)

10.  Kapoor 2008  The Post Colonial Politics of Development   Ch. 2 "The Culture of Development Policy"  (p. 19-37)

Who's Counting, Marilyn Waring

 

Imperialism, Colonialism and Independence

11.   McMichael  Ch2 "Instituting the Development Project"

12.  Weatherford "Indian Givers"

  1. -Ch. 2 Piracy, Slavery and the Birth of Corporations and
  2. -Ch. 3 The American Indian Path to Industrialization

Africa Episode - The Bible and the Gun and the Magnificent

African Cake.

 

The Other Side of The Leger

 

6

Crisis and Decline of National Developmentalism

13.  McMichael  Ch4 "Globalizing the National Economy"

14.   McMichael  Ch5 "Demise of the Third World"

15.  George, ‘How Poor Develop the Rich' (p. 207 213)

Africa: The Rise of Nationalism and The Legacy

7

Debt Crisis and the rise of Global institutions

16.  Hanlon "Debt and Development" (Haslam Ch. 14)

17.  Gwynne, S.C. 1983 "Adventures in the Loan Trade"

18.  Taylor "International Financial Institutions" (Haslam Ch. 9)

19.   McMichael  Ch6 "Instituting the Globalization Project"

 Life and Debt

Globalization TNC Capital Mobility, Labor Mobility and the Third World.

20.  Haslam  "Multinational Corporations" (Haslam Ch. 11)

21.  McMichael  Ch7 "The Globalization Project in Practice"

22.  Barndt (2008)"On the Move for Food: Truckers and Transnational Migrants" (p. 186-203)

China Blue

 

el Contrato

9

The Problems Of Canadian Democracy and Capitalism

23.  Linda McQuaig, "The Cult of Impotence"

24.   Valpy, "The foreign Policy Myth"

25.  Engler, “The Black Book of Canadian Foreign Policy” 4-21and 98-103

26.  Stephen Brown, "CIDA under the Gun" pp. 172-207

 

Bitter Paradise

 

Under Rich Earth

10

Development Assistance, NGOs and the Evolution of Canadian Foreign Aid Policy

27.  Brown "National Development Agencies and Bilateral Aid" (Haslam Ch. 8)

28.  Smillie "Foreign Aid and Canadian Purpose"

29.  M Kane "Canada and Africa"

The Skeptics' Journey

11

Indigenous People and Development

(The fourth world)

30.  T. Gordon, "Canadian Capitalism and dispossession of Indigenous peoples"

31.  J. Corntassel, "To be Ungovernable"

32.  Rutherford and Maracle  “Red  Power Legacies and Lives”

33.   Radcliffe and Laurie 2006 "Culture and Development: taking culture seriously in development for Andean indigenous people"

We Have Such Things at Home

 

The Ballad of Crowfoot

12

Where do we go from here?

34.  Cameron and A. Haanstra, "Development Made Sexy"

35.  McMichael Ch. 9 "Development For What"

36.  Peet and Hartwick, "Critical Modernism, Radical Democracy, Development" (p. 195-210)

Nature of Things: Accidental Revolution Part 1

 

Ricky Gervais

 

Thirst

Time Commitment

To complete the readings, assignments, and course activities, students can expect to spend, on average, about 15 - 18 hours per week on the course.

Course Resources

About SOLUS

SOLUS is Queen’s Student On-Line University System. You’ll have access to a SOLUS account once you become a Queen’s student. You’ll use SOLUS to register for courses, add and drop courses, update your contact information, view financial and academic information, and pay your tuition.

About MOODLE

Moodle is Queen's online learning platform. You'll log into Moodle to access your course. All materials related to your course—notes, readings, videos, recordings, discussion forums, assignments, quizzes, groupwork, tutorials, and help—will be on the Moodle site.

About Credit Units

Queen’s courses are weighted in credit units. A typical one-term course is worth 3.0 units, and a typical two-term course is worth 6.0 units. You combine these units to create your degree. A general (three-year) BA requires a total of 90 credit units.

Computer Requirements

To take an online course, you’ll need a good-quality computer (Windows XP/Vista/7, Pentium III, or Mac OS X 10.5, G4 or G5 processor, 256 MB RAM) with a high-speed internet connection, soundcard, speakers, and microphone, and up-to-date versions of free software (Explorer/Firefox, Java, Flash, Adobe Reader). See also Preparing For Your Course.

Dates/Deadlines

The deadlines for new applications to Queen’s are 1 April (for May summer term), 1 June (for July summer term), 1 August (for fall term), and 1 December (for winter term). All documents must be received by the 15th of the month following the deadline. You can register for a course up to one week after the start of the course. See also Dates and Deadlines.

Tuition Fees

Tuition fees vary depending when you start, your year, faculty, and program. Fees for 2014-15 first-year Distance Career Arts & Science Canadian students are as follows: for a 3.0-unit course, $605.31; for a 6.0-unit course, $1210.62. See also Tuition and Payment.

Campus Bookstore

All textbooks can be purchased at Queen’s Campus Bookstore.

Non-Queen’s Students

All Queen’s Arts and Science Online courses are open to students at other universities. Before applying as a visiting student, request a Letter of Permission from your home university that states that you have permission to take the course and apply it to your degree. See also Apply.

Academic Integrity

Please see Queen’s policy statement on academic integrity for information on how to complete an online course honestly.