Stage 2 - Defense: Preparing for Your Oral Examination
The student being examined must be present in person at Queen's University for their oral thesis examination.
The defense is a public presentation and discussion of the findings of the research program are conducted before a committee of selected faculty. This event marks the first time that the candidate truly expounds on and defends the meaning and significance of his or her research and knowledge of the discipline to peers and colleagues alike. Normally, it is open to attendance by all members of the Queen's community.
The master's thesis should demonstrate that the candidate is capable of original and independent work; that of a doctoral student must be original and be of such value as to merit publication.
The designated person in the student’s home department (the candidate, the supervisor, the graduate coordinator or graduate assistant) will schedule the Oral Thesis Examination by filling out the Oral Thesis Examination Form (Ph.D.; Master's). This form outlines the composition of the Thesis Examining Committee and the other details of the thesis examination.
- For doctoral students, the completed and signed form must reach the School of Graduate Studies no later than 25 working days before the tentative examination date.
- Master’s students must contact the Graduate Assistant or Graduate Coordinator in the Department for this deadline.
In preparation for the oral thesis examination, the candidate must submit one copy of the thesis, to each member of the Thesis Examining Committee including the Chairperson.
Distribution of the thesis copies to the examining committee must follow the same deadlines as outlined above.
Doctoral students: A PDF copy of the thesis must be submitted to the School of Graduate Studies (firstname.lastname@example.org) to be reviewed for formatting. The student will be notified of any required corrections. Please note: if the thesis is too large to send by e-mail, go to the link below for instructions on how to give access to the Thesis Coordinator to review your thesis on QSHARE.
Composition of the Thesis Examining Committee — Doctoral Programs:
- Chairperson - (selection made by the Thesis Coordinator)
- Head of the Department (or delegate)
- At least one other member of the Department
- At least one faculty member from another Department
- An external examiner from outside Queen's University
With the exception of the Chairperson for Doctoral Programs, it is the responsibility of the Department to select, verify eligibility, and invite all members of the Thesis Examining Committee.
Important: Final approval of the Thesis Examining Committee members lies with the Dean of the School of Graduate Studies.
Confidential Report Form: The Thesis Coordinator circulates the oral examination particulars and confidential report forms to each member of the Thesis Examining Committee by e-mail.
The reports must be submitted (in confidence), to the Thesis Coordinator for circulation to the Chairperson of the committee by the deadline date indicated. Each member of the Thesis Examining Committee must indicate whether the examination should be held, and if the candidate is permitted to defend the thesis.
Oral Thesis Examination Outcome Categories: At each oral thesis examination, the examining committee will reach one of the three outcome categories below:
These outcome categories are outlined in full detail in the Graduate School Regulations.
Oral Thesis Examination Form - Ph.D (PDF, 136 KB)
Permission from co-authors is always necessary if you are including full articles that have been published elsewhere (i.e. a manuscript style thesis). Please use the [Permission of Co-Authors] from to get permission and signatures from your co-authors.
In most cases, publishers will allow for journal articles and book chapters to be included in manuscript style theses without additional permissions. Check your publication agreements, the author rights section of the publisher site or the SHERPA RoMEO website for more information about what your publisher allows.
For more information on copyright permissions and your thesis go to the library website